ALFIE
- BILL BROUGHTON
The ingenuity of Bill Broughton was in his creating a character that
was totally self-centred and utterly immoral yet charming and very,
very funny. As played by Michael Caine, Alfie has gone on to
become an icon of 1960s British cinema though for younger generations
the re-make featuring Jude Law is perhaps better known than the
original. Of the two films the 1966 version is the superior for a
multitude of reasons that are just too numerous and too obvious to go
into here.
It's a funny thing, actually, how films can be re-made but books are
never re-written. Why is that?
The sexism displayed in Alfie is outrageous and many will nowadays
find it repulsive but if you can get your head around it and view it
as, for example, a comic device then Alfie stands as a brilliant book
on a par with anything written by Sartre or Camus. I choose these two
examples carefully because in my opinion Alfie is an English
existential anti-hero worthy of as much consideration as any
character created by these aforementioned authors.
Alfie is an Outsider in the classic Colin Wilson sense. He's detached
from the everyday preoccupations of everyone around him and instead
spends his time chasing a fugitive vision of freedom propelled by a
nagging feeling of absurd hopelessness in the face of life: "But
what's the answer, that's what I keep asking myself." he
says "No matter which way you turn you're caught. I go
through life with that question on my mind: what's the bleeding
answer?"
Alfie's philosophy and world view is forged through the prism of a
politically conservative working class life. He's a Cockney upstart
who's out for a good time and - as Arthur Seaton put it in the film
version of Saturday Night And Sunday Morning - all the rest is
propaganda. He sees money as being everything and that as "nobody
don't 'elp you in this life - you gotta 'elp yourself." He
views coalminers as being the backbone of the country and civil
servants as being a "steadying influence"; whilst
the only way to keep people working is to scare the life out of them.
He has little time for male friends, particularly for the blokey sort but spends his time instead with as many women as possible.
Alfie loves women and women love Alfie, the problem being, however,
that he loves them for only one reason and that's simply as a way of
bringing him pleasure. Respect for women just doesn't enter into it
and in fact, his view of them is so primitive that it makes for high
comedy. He calls women 'it' instead of 'her' or 'she' and to him they
just seem born to suffer: "Never stop a woman from working."
he says "If you do you'll get her frustrated. Poor bloody
women, they don't half suffer one way or another, but what can you
do? You can't argue with nature." He has little care for
their thoughts and believes "There's nothing a man enjoys
more than seeing a woman slaving away for him."
If his thoughts are shocking - "Know what, I sometimes think
this world would be a happier place if all the sick people and
whatnot dropped dead. When you get down to it they're only an
encumbrance to themselves and everybody else." - then his
actions are even more so. One of the main scenarios in the book is
regarding a back street abortion which takes place at his lodgings.
Alfie is the father and the pregnant woman is the wife of a fellow
patient at the hospital where Alfie stays whilst suffering from
tuberculosis. On inducing the woman, the abortionist hurries away and
Alfie puts his coat on to do the same:
"You're not going," says the pregnant woman "You're
not going to leave me, Alfie?"
"You'll be better on your own," he replies "It's
one of them things where nobody can help you - and you've got to
suffer it out on your own. Let go, Lily, and don't look at me like
that, as if I wasn't human. I could flannel you, but where would it
get us? If the pain comes on hard - stick a pillow in your mouth.
That'll drown the sound."
This event in the end does have a profound shock on him and he
decides to stop chasing "the birds" and to settle
down with one of his flames. He sets off for her flat with a bouquet
of flowers but when he arrives there he finds her in bed with another
man - in the book, one of his so-called friends though in the film
it's a younger man.
The book as does the film ends with Alfie contemplating the meaning
of it all: "Look at me now. I've got some money, haven't I,
and I've got a few good suits, a fair car, and I've got my health
back. But I haven't got my peace of mind. And if you haven't got that
you've got nothing.
But what's the answer? That's what I keep asking myself. I suppose
it's what everybody in this life is asking themselves."
In the film, of course, Michael Caine finishes his monologue by
asking "What's it all about? Know what I mean?"
before Cilla Black enters with the theme song asking the same
question: "What's it all about, Alfie? Is it just for the
moment we live?"
The book doesn't provide any easy answers, and instead simply depicts
the character of Alfie and poses the questions. His behaviour and his
attitude isn't condoned or condemned though it successfully shows him
as being a fool unto himself. The lesson Alfie fails to learn is to
learn from his lessons and it's this which keeps him rooted in one
place, condemning him to live what essentially is a very lonely life.
The women too are also foolish for putting up with Alfie's behaviour
and for entertaining his absurd opinions though they unlike him are
able to learn and in the end move on to better things.
Both the book and the film have always been presented as bawdy
comedies and whilst they are indeed both extremely funny and
entertaining they are also - the book in particular - deeply
philosophical. The Jude Law re-make has somewhat clouded the water by
transforming the whole story into a romantic comedy set in New York
but the original film is so much more than this and the original book
even more so and is deserving of reappraisal.
Know what I mean?
John Serpico