Thursday, 29 October 2026

Ida - Gertrude Stein

 IDA - GERTRUDE STEIN

It was Gertrude Stein who advised Paul Bowles to go to Tangiers, and from then on in regard to Tangiers and its connection with the Beat Generation, the rest is history. Brion Gysin, William Burroughs, Allen Ginsberg, Gregory Corso, Jack Kerouac, etc, all followed in Bowles' footsteps. 'There is no there there,' Gertrude Stein is famously quoted as saying, and this is true. There is only something you do or do not remember. This would suggest then, that Tangiers isn't so much a place but a state of mind and it's there that Stein advised Paul Bowles to go.
If this doesn't make any sense then Gertrude Stein's book, Ida, will make even less so. You see, Ida is not so much a book but a state of mind and one that I'm not sure I'd like to take up residency in because it's like a mind in a state of shock.


If you can imagine a young girl being held in a psychiatric hospital circa 1950, similar to the one Jack Nicholson entered in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, or Winona Ryder was sent to in Girl Interrupted. If you can imagine that young girl sat on her own, babbling away to herself about all kinds of nonsense that doesn't make any sense though it doesn't really matter because no-one's listening anyway. But then when sat opposite one of the doctors who's trying to diagnose her, she's babbling away in exactly the same manner and that doctor is thinking this might be a case where electro convulsive therapy could be helpful. That's Ida.

If you can imagine the lyrics of Mark E Smith of The Fall in full-on repetition mode but in book form, as in 'I drank a jar of coffee and then I took some of THESE! And I'm totally wired. Can't you see? T-t-t-t totally wired.' That's Ida. 'A butterfly stomach round ground...'

Plot? Story? There is no plot and there is no story. Things just happen and then they don't happen. A twin is born and then not born. Ida has a dog and then doesn't. Ida gets married time after time and then doesn't. Ida is Ida is Ida. Repetition repetition repetition. 'You don't have to be weird to be wired. You don't have to be strange to be strange,' to quote Mark E Smith again. Rose is a rose is a rose is a rose. Ida is Ida is Ida.
John Serpico

Tuesday, 20 October 2026

British Low Culture - From Safari Suits to Sexploitation - Leon Hunt

 BRITISH LOW CULTURE -
 FROM SAFARI SUITS TO SEXPLOITATION -
 LEON HUNT

If culture is not your friend, as ethnobotanist Terence McKenna once advised, does this mean that low culture is your mortal enemy? And what of British low culture specifically? Is it your nemesis? The metaphorical bullet with your name on? Enter into Leon Hunt's book British Low Culture and it needs to be done with trepidation because let's face it, the title is pretty loaded particularly with its added subtitle 'From Safari Suits to Sexploitation'. 
What exactly is 'low culture' and if such a thing can be defined is it cast as a good or a bad thing? Who's to judge? Who's the arbiter? In the blurb on the back of the book it mentions flares, lava lamps, safari suits, sexploitation films, skinhead novels, glam rock, and the mythology of wife-swapping suburbia. But hang on a minute. Is this implying that all these things are of no worth? As in low culture as opposed to high culture? Flares I'd agree with as they were always a waste of good cloth in the Seventies as well as the Madchester Nineties but everything else listed are some of my favourite things!


Leon Hunt's book was published in 1998 and there hasn't been a reprint since. The publisher is Routledge, who specialise in books of an academic nature which means Hunt is obviously an academic himself as well as a lecturer. Not that this is a bad thing, of course, but to be forewarned is to be forearmed.

'If you can remember the Seventies, you were there,' as comedian Jack Dee once said. The 1970s being always held up as an example of when culture turned naff. But isn't this by now a very boring yardstick? What exactly was better culturally about the Peter York/Robert Elms embellished 1980s than the BBC/ITV embellished 1970s? Between 'crumpet' and 'knockers' in the Seventies and 'birds' and 'tits' in the Eighties, there's not a lot of difference. There is, however, a difference between 'popular' and 'low' culture and that difference is often defined by 'authenticity', even if the term 'authenticity' itself is increasingly hard to define as the years pass.

Punk, of course, was the great leveller when it came to separating the authentic from the inauthentic but again as the years go by and our bullshit detectors in our garages become dulled, it's almost reached a point of where nobody really cares anymore because everything is simply product to consume without there being any real reasoning behind so-called choices. Essentially, for a lot of people 'I shop therefore I am' is all that really matters.

Leon Hunt's book is a dense affair, well-researched and packed with detail. Who would have thought that British TV comedy series from the Seventies were such cultural, political and sociological case studies? On The Buses, Are You Being Served?, Rising Damp, Man About The House - prime subjects for serious cultural studies all. As for Love Thy Neighbour, the fact that it was the most successful British sitcom from 1973 to 1975 tells us it was part of popular culture which alone begs a lot of questions, though the one to ask here is was it actually 'low culture'? Was it authentic?

This is where it starts to become problematic. The Sun newspaper was once part of popular culture too, but was The Sun 'low culture'? Was The Sun authentic? If so, then where did that leave The Guardian newspaper? It's at this point that a class analysis comes in handy, something that in a lot of academia is often missing. Thankfully there are times in Leon Hunt's book where he does indeed reveal a class consciousness and it's at these times that his book goes beyond navel-gazing and becomes genuinely illuminating, even if the reader needs to work on it due to these illuminations not being handed-over on a plate.


Hunt delves into the subjects of the Skinhead and Hell's Angels books from the New English Library stable, the wave of Confessions films starring the legendary Robin Askwith, the porn empire of David Sullivan and his Mary Millington films, and then finally the British horror film genre of the 1970s focusing specifically on the Hammer, Tyburn and Amicus films of that decade.

It's all good, interesting stuff written by somebody who clearly knows what he's talking about. And that's the beauty of it. British Low Culture is a serious book written by somebody who has thought seriously about the kind of subcultures that don't naturally invite examination. Importantly, Hunt doesn't set out to criticise but to understand. The icing on the cake of all this being the select filmography he supplies at the end that is an education in itself. Add to that all the films listed in the index then what you've got, essentially, is nothing less than a design for life.
John Serpico 

Monday, 5 October 2026

The Punk Reader - Dines, Gordon, Guerra

THE PUNK READER -
RESEARCH TRANSMISIONS FROM THE LOCAL AND THE GLOBAL -
MIKE DINES, ALASTAIR GORDON, PAULA GUERRA

Published in 2017, another more than welcome collection of scholarly debates from the Punk Scholars Network going under the title The Punk Reader - Research Transmissions From The Local And The Global. As declared on the back cover, the aim is to 'explore and critically interrogate punk culture in relation to contemporary, radicalised globalisation'. Well, whatever floats your boat is what I say. Some might argue, of course, that an academic study of the so-called 'punk phenomenon' isn't warranted and is in fact, anathema to the very idea of punk. But it's horses for courses at the end of the day. 
Punk was never a closed shop or an exclusive gentlemen's drinking club even if some people tried their hardest to make it so. No, punk was a free-for-all, meaning if you wanted it as a space to sniff glue and bang your head against a wall then that's fine. If you wanted it as a cultural equivalent of the Baader-Meinhof Group then that's fine also. And if you wanted to come along with your clipboard and your pen, take notes and compose a revolutionary thesis on what you observe, then all power to you. Punk isn't mine to claim as my own and neither is it yours. Punk is all of ours. Apart, obviously, from Richard Branson's. He can fuck right off.


Where punk was born as in New York or London is a timeless question but The Punk Reader isn't concerned with that. Instead, it's more interested in where it's gone to and where it's at. You see, punk nowadays is global and is all the more better for it. On its inception, like an incurable ever-mutating virus, punk spread out from the major cities and into the towns; its different strains erupting gloriously throughout the UK, North America, the whole of Europe, and the Far and Middle East. Admittedly, there's still yet to be an Eskimo punk band but give it time.

One of the multitude of questions this all led to was that of 'authenticity', and straight off the block this is what co-founder of the Punk Scholars Network, Alastair Gordon, races into with a keenness of mind and a passion of lovers. And where do questions of authenticity tend to lead to? Why, to Chumbawamba of course, with them from their very start being representative of 'anarcho-authenticity' up until their signing to EMI.
'Bare faced hypocrisy sells records' as one particularly grieved punk wag put it on a record of the same name in regard to the Chumbawamba/EMI debacle but one of the things that Gordon makes clear in his chapter is that the world is not black-and-white even though 'bare faced hypocrisy sells records' is a very true statement to make - and not only in regard to Chumbawamba.


You might not think it but punk is a very convoluted, distorted and twisted affair that always has been and always will be ripe for taking seriously. Tony D of Ripped And Torn/Kill Your Pet Puppy fanzines knew this, which is why when he first encountered Crass through being passed a copy of their demo tape was at first confused by it before realising how important it was because '
At last' as Tony put it 'punk was being taken seriously'.

Ah, Crass. Our let's pretend passport to perversity. Crass: like Morrissey's Manchester - so much to answer for. Their ghost haunts the pages of The Punk Reader like smoke lingers round your fingers and it's a legacy earned, a legacy deserved, and a legacy of resonance that reflects well upon those whom they've influenced. Those such as the punks of Groningen, in Holland, for example, of whom Kirsty Lohman writes of in her chapter in the book.
But then it was always going to be a match made in heaven when it came to the Netherlands and punk, particularly when it came to Dutch squatting history and the Crass vision. And indeed, Groningen was one of the handful of places Crass back in 1980 ever played outside of the UK. 
A country they never played, however, is Malaysia although according to Marco Ferrarese in his chapter, you might think Crass were in residence there as the anarcho punk aesthetic is the signifier of Malaysian punk authenticity to this day, right down to the black clothes and the use everywhere of the same font Crass used on their record sleeves.


An important point in regard to global influence is raised in the chapter by Augusto Santos Silva and Paula Guerra to extinguish any ideas of punk being a form of cultural imperialism or as some sort of 'British invasion'. Instead, the term 'cultural syncretism' is used, meaning multi-cultural cross-pollination, resulting in punk mutations with 'substantially different attributes to the original version'.
If you think of punk as being a form of Chaos Theory where the flapping of a butterfly's wings on one side of the world causes a tornado on the other side, then it starts to make sense. Unlike the expanding symmetry of fractals, however, where a fractal reproduces its same self into infinity, punk bears localised hybrids. Like strange flowers born from seeds blown on a breeze. Is it any wonder why those of an academic bent might find punk such a thing of interest?

For all that, it's easy to criticise The Punk Reader for its general aesthetic as in being a very dry read, but then dryness is almost the very nature of most academic writing and it's hard to break out of that without diluting the whole purpose of it. Without throwing the baby out with the bathwater. It's also always very obvious whenever a thesis attempts to break out of its academic mode into a more flowing and easier-on-the-brain format as it often comes across as a sort of insult, as if the writer or editor is dumbing everything down to make it easier for non-academics to understand. Well, as Dean Friedman almost said, academics can thank their lucky stars we're not as smart as we'd like to think we are, or else they'd all be out of a job.

At the end of the day, academic writing in regard to punk is a niche space and there's room for it, and it's a more than welcome inclusion onto the sprawling tapestry that punk has become. In fact, anything that instigates or invites critical thinking of any sort should be welcomed for as Johnny Rotten once said of the Sex Pistols: 'We make people think, and that's dangerous - for those who'd like to make us morons.'
John Serpico