Saturday, 28 October 2023

New Poems Book One - Charles Bukowski

 NEW POEMS BOOK ONE - CHARLES BUKOWSKI

Charles Bukowski was never an alcoholic as such, though he was certainly a drunkard. Let's just say he liked a bit of a drink and that he made a good drunk, if there can be such a thing? Bukowski knew how to drink. Often he would just shut himself up in his rented room, close the curtains, prop himself up on his bed and swig down bottles of the most noxious, cheapest wine he could find and drink himself into oblivion. He knew, however, to always lie on his side when slipping into unconsciousness so as not to end up choking on his own vomit. It's the little things in life such as this that are important and what differentiates the amateur from the professional. It's a sort of life skill, in a way. One that in the scheme of things is probably more important than being able to write. And Charles Bukowski certainly knew how to write, just as certainly as he knew how to drink.


New Poems Book One is part of an archive of  work that Bukowski left to be published after his death in 1994. It's a collection of random poems though I'd hazard a guess and say a fair few of them were originally written as vignettes and then edited into poems. Some of them are but cursory glances and wry observations but others are moments of reflection and illumination captured for eternity.

In one piece, entitled The Column, Bukowski describes how in 1942 at the age of 21 he's sitting on a park bench alongside a bunch of other bums when 'the war chariots' roll by, and how the soldiers on their way to war see him and hate him. Bukowski describes the soldiers yelling, cursing and screaming at him because they want him to be going with them. After the column passes, one of the old bums next to him asks Bukowski why he's not in the Service, at which Bukowski gets up and walks down to the public library where he sits down at a table and starts reading. The meaning of the book is too deep for him, however, so he puts it back on the shelf and walks back outside 'to wait'.
There are some who won't understand what Bukowski is talking about here but for those who do, it's like suddenly recognising a kindred spirit.


If you feel there's something wrong with the world, something you can see with your own eyes but that you can't put into words, then what do you do? Well, there's very little that you can do. How can you talk about it if you don't have the words? How do you explain not only to others but to yourself? And then one day if you finally have the words then who do you talk to if others don't share those words also? The answer is that you don't talk, you write. And that's exactly what Charles Bukowski did.

In a piece entitled Commerce, Bukowski remembers his father's words of 'work hard and you'll be appreciated' but later Bukowski learns that this is true only if you make much more for them than they pay you. 'America at work, where they rip out your intestines and your brain and your will and your spirit. They suck you dry, then throw you away. The capitalist system. The work ethic. The profit motive.'

In another piece entitled The Great Escape, Bukowski relays a conversation between himself and a colleague at work one day, where his colleague is comparing working for the postal service to a bucket full of crabs. Every now and then, his colleague tells him, a crab will climb on top of the others and begin to climb toward the top of the bucket and just as it's about to escape, another crab will grab it and pull it back down. Mid-conversation, a supervisor approaches Bukowski and his colleague and says 'you fellows were talking. There is no talking allowed on this job'.
Eleven and one-half years Bukowski has been working there so he gets up off his stool and climbs right up the supervisor, reaches up and pulls himself right out of there. 'It was so easy it was unbelievable,' Bukowski writes 'but none of the others followed me, And after that, whenever I had crab legs I thought about that place. I must have thought about that place maybe 5 or 6 times - before I switched to lobster.'


Bukowski became a writer and years later as he describes in another piece entitled About The Mail, people write to him to say that his books have helped them through tough times. And there was Bukowski thinking his writing was for the purpose of keeping him from going under but it now appears he's helped any number of others. 'Well, being helped happened to me too,' he writes, and then goes on to list those who he means: 'Celine, Dostoevsky, Fante, early Saroyan, Turgenev, Gorky, Sherwood Anderson, Robinson Jeffers, E E Cummings, Blake, Lawrence and many others.'
It's an interesting reading list, particularly in regard to his admission in The Column that he didn't understand the book he had pulled off the shelf at the library and therefore had 'to wait'. Waiting obviously paid off because once he was ready he devoured the most heaviest of books and this time understood their meaning. Consecutively his own writing came bursting out of him. Roaring out of him, even, as it should do if you're ever going to call yourself a writer.

Bukowski can be a divisive figure. His writing appeals to some but to others it repels. It's undeniable, however, that when he's good he's very, very good indeed. The main problem with him was that he was never consistently good and sometimes came across as a sexist, negative boor. Happily, there's no such problems here in this particular book.
John Serpico

Friday, 20 October 2023

White Line Fever - Lemmy Kilmister

WHITE LINE FEVER -
LEMMY KILMISTER

Well, it starts off with an anecdote about being thrown off a plane after being spotted sipping from a bottle of Jack Daniels by a stewardess, and Lemmy's explanation for boarding a plane with a pint of Jack Daniels in his pocket is that he finds it helps with the sobering up. And it continues in the same vein from there, really.
There's a knack when it comes to writing an autobiography and whilst some people have it others clearly don't have it at all. 'A man needs to know his limitations', as Clint Eastwood's Dirty Harry says in The Enforcer, and Lemmy against all the evidence clearly knew his which is presumably why he got in writer Janiss Garza to help out? Lemmy might well have been a God as Dave Grohl once stated but he was also a professional who knew he owed it not only to his fans but also to his reputation to not present a badly-written book. You only write one autobiography in your life (unless you're John Lydon) so it should never be a half-arsed one.


White Line Fever reads as if you're sat down in your living room at the end of an evening and Lemmy's there with you, laid out and relaxed on your sofa, drinking double brandies and pulling on a cigar as he regales you with the story of his life. It's very personable, very friendly and very entertaining. But what would we want from a Lemmy Kilmister autobiography? Well, we would want things we never knew before. Little facts and details to fill the gaps and flesh out the bigger picture. And we would want anecdotes and good ones too about 'huge women doing things to him with raw carrots', as an example - and those are Lemmy's words, not mine.

'Motorhead', of course, is American slang for speedfreak so with such a blatant drugs reference from the get go, it's no surprise that Lemmy has a lot of drug anecdotes. His time in Hawkwind in particular is an example of drug taking on an industrial scale with tales of three-week speed binges, going berserk on belladonna, and of talking to trees on acid, with the trees sometimes winning the argument.
Come 1980 Lemmy put in for a blood transplant, the same process Keith Richards is rumoured to have gone through. After some blood tests, however, his doctor informed him that it's not going to be possible because he no longer had human blood anymore. 'Pure blood will kill you,' his doctor told him 'And you can't give blood either. Forget it, you'd kill the average person because you're so toxic.'
So Lemmy was a medical phenomena. Half man half pharmacy. 


Drugs do things to a person, and according to Lemmy they certainly did something to Mitch Mitchell, the drummer in the Jimi Hendrix Experience who bounced up to Lemmy one day in the middle of Oxford Street and exclaimed 'Hello, I don't know who I am!' before running off again. Drugs also might have done something to Dave Brock of Hawkwind who Lemmy says developed a habit of leaning out of his car as he drove along and yelling at schoolgirls 'Spank! Spank! Spank! Hello, girls, spanky-spanky!' As for Nik Turner, let's just not go there, shall we?


When it came to a lot of things, Lemmy was totally unreconstructed. Some of his more lurid tales in regard to his relationships and backstage conquests are questionable and though his attitude toward women was one of macho hyper-sexuality he always held women in much respect and love. Interestingly and thankfully he always remained very perceptive, at one point in the book when talking about him getting gastric flu even going into Nostradamus mode: 'These viral things are gonna keep getting stronger, 'cause every five years a new strain comes out that they didn't plan on, and some day one of those bugs is gonna kill half the planet.' He was saying this in 2002.

White Line Fever is a good read and is definitely one of the better rock autobiographies. Though seeing as it's the autobiography of the once snorting, drinking rock god legend that was Lemmy Kilmister, you really wouldn't want or expect anything less.
John Serpico

Friday, 29 September 2023

Dreamers - Knut Hamsun

 DREAMERS - KNUT HAMSUN

Knut Hamsun does 'whimsy' and who'd have thought? After the delirium of his masterpiece, Hunger, it would be reasonable to expect more of the same from the writer who Charles Bukowski once described as 'one of the greatest writers ever' but Hamsun is just full of surprises, some of them welcome some of them not so. Against what is probably my better judgement, Knut Hamsun is one of my favourite writers though I wouldn't go so far as Bukowski in saying he was one of the greatest. 
Just as Bukowski could no doubt have explained why Hamsun was so good (and I can probably guess why he would have held that view, particularly after having read Hunger) I could just as easily explain why he's one of my favourites though I don't think it would be very helpful to anyone or even myself. Sometimes something just is, and it's best to just leave it at that. A bit like life, really.


Dreamers was written in 1904 and is set in a small, isolated fishing village in northern Norway where we follow the trials and tribulations of Ove Rolandsen, the village telegraph operator as he drinks, fights, flirts and schemes. He's not the only one though. All the residents of the village are at it even if only within the privacy of their own homes. From housekeepers, factory owners, lay-helpers, curates and even wives of curates, they're all flirting and scheming like cast members of an endless soap opera. Roalandsen the telegraph operator is the biggest, however, albeit all done with an almost innocent charm.

In the way of storyline, there isn't much to say without giving away spoilers only that it's beautifully crafted and misses not a beat. It's precise, subtle, light, wry, amusing and a joy to read. What makes it all very likeable in fact reminded me of the magic realism as captured by Hilary Mantel in her 1989 novel, Fludd. Even more so, it very much reminded me of Federico Fellini's 1973 film Amacord, where the village of Fellini's childhood is depicted as a place of comical, beautiful and magical strangeness. Compare and contrast. Amacord being, in fact, one of my all-time favourite films so comparing Hamsun's Dreamers to it is actually high praise indeed.
John Serpico

Sunday, 17 September 2023

Jimi - Curtis Knight

 JIMI - AN INTIMATE BIOGRAPHY OF JIMI HENDRIX -
CURTIS KNIGHT

According to Curtis Knight, apparently Jimi Hendrix was a messenger from another world. 'Genius guitarist, sent from another time and another place, to give us a message of Love, Peace and Freedom'. Well, I'm not too sure about that. We know Hendrix was a genius guitarist because we've heard him, we know he was a fantastic performer because we've seen him, and we know he was the Penis de Milo of plaster casts because we've seen it, but a messenger from another world sent from another time and another place? I think I'll take that bit with a pinch of salt. And on that point it very much sums up a lot of this book.


Jimi, by Curtis Knight, is written from the perspective of the author who worked with and was friends with Hendrix prior to Hendrix leaving America for England in 1966, with the friendship remaining right up until Hendrix's death in 1970. The fact that Knight was close to Hendrix is of benefit when writing a biography such as this but it also means that what he does is to weave himself into the story as well and quite often it's hard to tell what is true and what is him simply hitching himself onto the Hendrix comet tail in a bid to boost his own importance and his own credentials.

Fairly prominent in the book is the issue of recordings released by Knight that weren't ever welcomely received by the music press, recordings that Knight was accused of releasing in a bid to cash in on Hendrix's death. There are two tracks in particular, both of which make for interesting listening that now with the benefit of YouTube are easily accessible.
The first is a song called How Would You Feel that was recorded in 1965, which is very similar to Dylan's Like A Rolling Stone, a song of course that Hendrix practically made his own. The second is a song called The Ballad Of Jimi, again recorded in 1965 almost five years before Hendrix's death where the lyrics are all about him having already died.


Knight tells us that after Hendrix's return to America in 1967 after having spent a year in England, they met up again to discuss among other things the contract Hendrix had broken when he departed for England. Their friendship was immediately rekindled and they went into a recording studio and over just one night recorded a whole album together. Now, this to me sounds mightily implausible. That Jimi Hendrix, after having already released his debut album and established himself in Europe would - on his way to the Monterey Pop Festival - without any objection from his Management enter a studio with his old friend and record a whole album in one session? 
'That is my position, and that is the real story,' King writes. Well, I'm not so sure.

Die-hard Hendrix fans would probably already know about all the legal wrangling that entailed and the settlements over royalties just as they would probably know about some of the other stories Curtis writes about such as The Jimi Hendrix Experience going on tour with The Monkees - a mismatch almost made in heaven. They would probably even know that someone at one point stole Hendrix's gravestone? For all that, there are still other anecdotes they maybe wouldn't be aware of, particularly in regard to private conversations between Curtis and Hendrix. Take the subject of the Electric Ladyland cover design for example, with the photograph of twenty or so nude girls. According to Curtis, Hendrix didn't like it much but there was nothing he could do. "They never consulted me about those kind of things," Hendrix is quoted as saying. 


Near to the end of the book there's a chapter about Hendrix's last few days in London just before he died in 1970 which is interesting to read as it's all about him walking among the trees and gardens in Hyde Park, or floating around Notting Hill, Kensington Market and the Fulham Road. It's interesting because it seems strange to imagine him - this Rock'n'Roll icon, this Rock God - just wandering around these places, almost as if the surroundings doesn't match the legend. A bit like reading about Nico of The Velvet Underground ending up on heroin in Manchester.

Overall, the book does offer some insights but not really enough to add anything new to the story of Hendrix's life or to make it essential reading. Much better - as is often the case - to just listen instead to the music because a lot of it really is the music of the spheres that still to this day in terms of guitar playing remains unsurpassed.
John Serpico

Friday, 8 September 2023

The Friends Of Eddie Coyle - George V Higgins

 THE FRIENDS OF EDDIE COYLE - GEORGE V HIGGINS

The book on which the 1973 film starring Robert Mitchum was based and the only thing wrong with it is the cover because if the guy in the picture is meant to be the main character, Eddie 'Fingers' Coyle, then it looks nothing like him. The book describes Coyle as being stocky and in his forties which fits Robert Mitchum's description but the guy on the cover is at least ten years younger and not stocky in the slightest. Perhaps it's meant to be one of the other main characters, the gun seller by the name of Jackie Brown? It's unlikely though, and probably more to do with not paying proper attention.
It's not a bad cover, of course, and it's actually a good picture - painted, interestingly enough, by Paul Roberts, who went on to being the vocalist for British rock band Sniff 'n' The Tears who had a world-wide hit with the song Driver's Seat.


Apart from the issue with the cover, The Friends Of Eddie Coyle by George V Higgins is classic pulp fiction. It's a crime caper involving a gang of hardened criminals robbing a series of banks who like to use a new set of guns every time they rob a new bank. The guns are being supplied to the gang by Eddie Coyle who gets them from a gun dealer called Jackie Brown. And that's the gist of it but being a crime caper the cast of characters is going to be a nest of vipers with everyone playing everybody off against one another, including girlfriends, bar-owners and police.

The whole pace of the story suits Robert Mitchum's demeanour perfectly as it's very languid, very world-weary, very life at the end of its tether. It's totally narrative-driven with conversations and monologues written phonetically in an often surreal, wise-guy vernacular. The bottom line is that it's a joy to read and is the perfect example of why books such as this are so good. They're not a challenge, they're not written to educate or to make the reader think, or as a vehicle for any kind of lesson in morality. They're written to be read - actually. They're written to entertain and to make the act of reading a pleasure not a chore.
The film of the book is a classic, directed by Peter Yates (who also directed Bullitt) that as well as starring Robert Mitchum also stars Peter Boyle. It's a perfect cast and the book in a similar fashion is perfect pulp fiction.
John Serpico

Monday, 28 August 2023

The Drought - J G Ballard

 THE DROUGHT - J G BALLARD

Is it fanciful to imagine the occurrence of a world-wide drought? I can assure you, it's most certainly not. J G Ballard wrote his novel, The Drought, in 1965 and now just almost 60 years later it looks mightily prescient. In Ballard's book the drought is caused by a pollution-generated membrane forming over the world's oceans preventing all evaporation of surface water into the air above, leading subsequently to no clouds being formed and subsequently to no rain. It's not a sudden occurrence at all but a gradual build-up over ten years, the first major effect of it being food shortages due to seasonal rainfalls failing to materialize in important agricultural regions.
Farmlands turn to arid dust-basins, reservoirs and rivers run dry, and the world goes awry as cities are abandoned. Populations head to the coasts to be nearer to water even if it's undrinkable. Huge distillation units are constructed and run by the army before being taken over by citizens' militias as millions of people start living in cars and shacks on the beaches that turn into salt dunes from the distillation process. Water, food and guns become the currency, anything else is useless surplus apart from such things as abandoned cars which act as make-shift coffins.


The actual plot and storyline of Ballard's book isn't really up to much and although this is a bit of a problem (as well as the fact that it could have been edited a lot better) it doesn't really matter because the premise is all. Ballard is essentially imagining what it would be like if a world-wide drought was to occur, focusing on a stretch of England not more than a hundred miles in diameter. We're not just talking a seasonal drought here, it should be said, but one that stretches over a ten-year period.

Society, of course, collapses as the landscape turns to desert. There being no water means there being no crops, which means there is no livestock. The only food to be had is from scavenged canned goods and fish from the sea. Fiefdoms of various sizes are established whilst other groups eke out an existence on the peripheries.
Apart from the initial mass exodus from the cities to the coasts there is no great, uncontrolled panic that takes hold, just a gradual but inexorable slide into desperate living. There is almost a complacency about it all, an abandonment of hope against the inevitable. At times it's reminiscent of Nevil Shute's On The Beach, where against the slow but inescapable approach of mass death by radiation from a nuclear war, people tend to try and continue as normal. Taking it on the chin with grim acceptance as the surreal becomes the new normal.

So, could such a vision of the future ever become reality? That is the question. Could such a drought as described by Ballard ever happen? Could the water to our cities, to our agriculture, to our homes simply one day run out? The answer - worryingly, disturbingly, depressingly - is 'yes'.
Who could ever have imagined that one day the world's economic systems might be closed down and whole populations told to stay at home and to not venture out? This is one of the great lessons from the Covid pandemic: to not dismiss anything as being impossible and for it to be said it could never happen. Imagine the unimaginable and then with a cold, clear eye just look to see how far we might actually be from it. Or rather, how close we actually are.
John Serpico

Friday, 25 August 2023

Fight Back - Punk, Politics And Resistance - The Subcultures Network

 FIGHT BACK - PUNK, POLITICS AND RESISTANCE -
THE SUBCULTURES NETWORK

The obvious question to ask in regard to a book called Fight Back - Punk, Politics And Resistance is 'What's the point of it?' What is its intention? What is its aim? If writing about music is like dancing to architecture, then what is writing about punk as a space for political expression and action? According to the blurb on the back cover, the book's objective is 'to advance general and scholarly understanding of punk and youth culture more broadly, and to reveal the importance of youth culture as a site of political expression and to stimulate scholarly interest in the relationship between subcultures, popular music and social change.'
So it's a crash course for the ravers? A drive-in Saturday?


If approaching this book either as a reader or even as one of the contributors seeking or looking to provide an explanation of punk, then from the start you're barking up the wrong tree. If you need to have punk explained to you then it's obviously something not for you, so you might just as well spend your seed on some other more fertile ground so it might bear some fruit of actual use to you. If you feel the need to explain punk to others then you need to think twice and ponder the cliche about that which is taught by the teacher themselves need to learn the most.
That being said, what then is this weighty tome called Fight Back? What is this punk rock axe to grind? Well, without being overly dramatic, all this punk rock stuff is the stuff of life. Take away the 'rock' and what you're left with is the substance: Punk. Fight Back, then, is a collection of essays written by various academics and scholars and collated by the University of Reading-hosted Subcultures Network. And yes, it's a weighty tome but then so it should be, because it's a weighty subject it deals with. It's not a frivolous book, you might say.

If a tree falls in a forest and there's no-one around to hear it, does it make a sound? Is there any one singular meaning to life? The answer is ultimately 'yes' but when you think you know it, you're most likely going to be wrong so instead it makes better sense to be aware of multiple meanings that will bring you just as much benefit on whatever level you're looking at it on.
It's an uncomfortable truth but as ethnobotanist Terence McKenna once said 'Culture is not your friend', and once you understand this then things can start to be put into perspective and can be seen as to what is important and what is not so. This then begs the question, however, that if culture is not your friend then is subculture even less so? It's a pertinent point and it's actually here that things get interesting. 


Punk was originally a subculture that following the Bill Grundy/Sex Pistols debacle became an overnight mainstream culture, entering into public discourse. With this transformation a lot of the nuances, subtleties and contradictions within the original punk idea were lost, to be replaced by much more simple and much more easier to communicate messages and signals. Due to punk's very contradictory nature, however, those nuances and numerous unresolved contradictions though hidden, remained like honey at the core. Like essence rare.
Punk in the cultural mainstream needed to be played out and its main players to crash and burn for the nuances and contradictions to take root. They needed to be left alone and shielded to allow them to grow and even flourish, to be later explored and encouraged. In one respect, this explains the later rise of the New Punk, Crass, and Oi! scenes.

And yes, there it is: the dreaded Oi! word. The subculture within punk culture that still to this day has - as Matthew Worley points out in what is one of the best essays in the book - resisted assimilation into the 'respectable' narrative that now binds punk more generally into the nation's cultural fabric.
Oi! is the bete noir of punk, politics and resistance because of its confrontational adherence to its working class origins, and why this has caused such a problem speaks volumes. Much to his credit, Worley approaches Oi! with an open mind and in doing so concludes 'meanings have been projected onto Oi! rather than drawn from it' and that in actual fact 'Oi! was far closer to what its adherents claimed it to be than it was to what its critics accused it of being.'
And what did Oi!'s critics accuse it of being? Racist, sexist, homophobic, violent and parochial. An incubator, essentially, for Right-wing ideology. The same Right-wing ideology spewed day in day out by the Daily Mail and the Telegraph to their middle class readerships but did you ever see a so-called Nazi bonehead reading these newspapers? No. Their chosen source of news would always be The Sun and the Daily Mirror, and whilst The Sun was always Right-wing it was on a comic level and never as insidious and mean-spirited as the Daily Mail, and never as humourless and straight-faced as the Telegraph. Worley concludes that the way Oi! was castigated is an early example of what is nowadays labelled the 'demonisation of the working class', which is basically the editorial policy of the Right-wing press. All in all it's a very good essay and one that needed to be written.


So too for Peter Webb's essay on 'Crass, subculture and class' if only for the fact that any book on 'punk, politics and resistance' that doesn't include Crass is either ill-informed or in denial. Essentially, Webb describes the milieu created around Crass that enabled people from different class backgrounds to come together and creatively work towards a shared though very individualistic transcendentalism. What the essay does as well - if even inadvertently - is to highlight that the areas in which Crass were strongest such as in their promotion of pacifism and their rejection of class were also their weakest - their Achilles Heels. 
The issue of class had always been a thorn in their side from the start but it was the Falklands War that brought it to a head. Rather than chastising themselves for being too slow off the mark for not including anything about the Falklands on their newly released album at the time, what Crass missed was that it was working class boys (on both British and Argentinian sides) who were being killed. That it was working class boys who were sacrificed to protect the ship that Prince Andrew was on. Come the miners' strike of 1984, it was working class mining communities that Thatcher was destroying, not 'classless' enclaves in leafy suburbia.
To Crass, class may have mattered less than not eating meat but in the end it was issues around class and the way to deal with them as in violently or non-violently that tore them apart. In hindsight, Crass were hoisted on their own petard and if not slain were mortally wounded by their enemies because they didn't understand their enemies. Taking on Thatcher, for example, without understanding that Thatcher was out to destroy working class power (in the form of unions) and working class ethics (such as helping your neighbour and community solidarity); replacing these things instead with an accent on the individual (as in 'no such thing as society') and greed being good, well - Crass politically were on a hiding to nothing.
For all that, Peter Webb's essay is useful and somewhat important in regard to culture and resistance because it gives rise for such questions on the significance of class to be considered. It's often like opening a can of worms, it should be said, but it's also something that shouldn't be shied away from.


At another tangent, Jonathyne Briggs in his essay questions why punk initially failed to take off in France, and actually it's a really interesting question. All the right ingredients were there for punk in France to become huge: Geographically it was just across the water from the London punk explosion, just a bit more of a distance in fact as that between London and Manchester. It was only 9 years after the events of May '68 so there should still have been elements and remnants of revolutionary zeal in France, embers still glowing and just waiting to be blown to life again by a fresh wind. The Pistols, The Damned and The Clash went over to France to play in the very early days of punk, before they'd even played a lot of places in England. Metal Urbain from France recorded a version of Anarchy In The UK and were the first band to have a record released on the Rough Trade label. And of course there were all the Situationist slogans adopted by Jamie Reid for the Pistols. 
With all this, punk should maybe have been even bigger in France than in England? So why didn't it happen? Briggs puts it down to any development of a French punk subculture being hindered due to being unable to find its own identity, becoming instead a caricature in terms of fashion and musical conventions. I'm not sure this is completely true but it's an interesting notion, particularly as it begs the question if whether 'the perception of conventions that govern subcultures also confound their movement?'


Giacomo Botta's essay on the other hand suggests the complete opposite, that punk represents a complex set of ideologies and practices that transcend any specific national culture, an example of this he cites as being the Colettivo Punx Anarchici of Torino, in Italy.
But then we have another essay concerning Czech punks and skinheads where the authors suggest that subcultural identity is, in part, determined by the nature of the dominant society in which it's situated and it's relationship to subcultures that differentiate against one another.
In another essay concerning punk in East Germany, the author declares that 'punk does not exist outside of the society but within an existing framework of values, expectations and social norms'. Which is probably more like it, if not indeed very true.

All of this and more goes to show that punk is a lot more than just heads down no nonsense mindless boogie, though it should be said that Fight Back isn't going to be for everyone due in the main to it being academic and the essays presented in that typical thesis style with lots of footnotes to back everything up. The foreword to the book is written by Steve Ignorant and call me a cynic but I don't believe for one moment that he actually read the whole thing. I mean, why should he? And if he did, then he would have spotted some of the glaring mistakes in one of the essays concerning the Crass and Small Wonder labels.
The afterword, however, is an interview conducted by Matthew Worley with writer Jon Savage, presented in a typical, fanzine-style verbatim question and answer format where Savage discusses the cultural impact of punk. It's a very good interview, full of interesting and thought-provoking ideas - and it's accessible. I'd wager, in fact, that if any of the book it would have been this part that Steve Ignorant read and if he didn't then he should have done because in it Savage heaps a lot of praise upon Crass.
Above all else, however, the important thing is that Fight Back is food for thought, and in an age of oven-ready Brexit deals, post-truth Trumpian world views, and of culture wars waged by neo-conservatives in free fall, this can only be a good thing.
John Serpico